News & Supplemental  

Worry About the West — Not Israel

by Vic­tor Davis Hanson

The reac­tions and media cov­er­age com­ing out of the West regard­ing this lat­est war in the Mid­dle East are as bewil­der­ing as they are instructive.

Rep. John Din­gell, D-Mich., for exam­ple, recently said, “I don’t take sides for or against Hezbol­lah or for or against Israel .”

Mean­while, the West­ern news agency Reuters, respond­ing to scrutiny by blog­gers, with­drew wire pho­tos taken by a free­lance pho­tog­ra­pher of a smoky and burn­ing Beirut . Reuters had failed to catch the freelancer’s doc­tor­ing of the pho­tos to empha­size unduly the dam­age from Israeli bombs.

And the Asso­ci­ated Press notes that ini­tially reported Lebanese claims of 40 “civil­ians” killed by Israeli air strikes at Houla, Lebanon, in fact, were mis­taken — and that the lat­est reports have low­ered the death toll to one.

In Qana, where the Israeli mil­i­tary had hit an apart­ment build­ing (and were quickly cen­sured by Euro­pean states­men), the num­ber of civil­ian fatal­i­ties reported also kept decreas­ing as reports were scru­ti­nized. Plus, we have learned that sev­eral hours lapsed between the drop­ping of the bombs and the fatal col­lapse of the build­ing, rais­ing fur­ther ques­tions about the rela­tion­ship between the bomb­ing and the fatal­i­ties that fol­lowed. Finally, based on pho­tographs from the scene, the onsite res­cue appeared staged for reporters.

These dis­crep­an­cies sug­gest we have lit­tle idea what actu­ally hap­pened on the ground there — other than that Qana has been a favored missile-launching site against Israel , as a recent deadly aer­ial assault from there on Haifa attests.

There is a depress­ing pat­tern here. The sources for West­ern erro­neous reports and faked pic­tures always seem to exag­ger­ate the dam­age to Lebanon — but never to Israel .

Like­wise, West­ern news agen­cies rarely list a pre­cise num­ber of Hezbol­lah losses, instead lump­ing them in with civil­ian fatal­i­ties. Does that mean that some­one who launches a mis­sile in Levis and sneak­ers is not a combatant?

In addi­tion, the his­tory and nature of Hezbol­lah do not mat­ter to many in the West.

Know­ingly or not, news out­lets con­tinue to spread Hezbollah’s pro­pa­ganda. One won­ders if West­ern­ers remem­ber or know that, until Sept. 11, Hezbol­lah had killed more Amer­i­cans than had any other ter­ror­ist organization.

Most ignore as well that Hezbol­lah pre­cip­i­tated the present cri­sis by kid­nap­ping and killing Israeli sol­diers, and launch­ing mis­siles against Israel ‘s cities.

In retal­i­a­tion, the Israeli Defense Forces use pre­ci­sion bombs to tar­get com­bat­ants and try to avoid civil­ian casu­al­ties (though the lat­ter is nearly impos­si­ble against an enemy who doesn’t wear uni­forms and uses non-combatants as “human shields”). In con­trast, every ran­dom mis­sile launched by Hezbol­lah is intended to hit a civil­ian target.

On one side of this con­flict is a true democ­racy that was attacked. On the other are ter­ror­ists who hijacked the sov­er­eign gov­ern­ment of Lebanon , insti­tuted theo­cratic rule over a third of the coun­try — and started a war.

Hezbol­lah, of course, has been enabled in large part thanks to Iran­ian petro-dollars and intim­i­da­tion. But the nature of Hezbollah’s patrons doesn’t seem to mat­ter to many West­ern­ers, either.

Those now call­ing for “dia­logue” with the “major play­ers” ignore that Iran promises to wipe out Israel . The French for­eign min­is­ter was quick to praise the regional role of theo­cratic Iran as “stabilizing.”

Then there’s Hezbollah’s other patron, Syria, a coun­try that bru­tally occu­pied Lebanon, har­bors ter­ror­ists and is sus­pected of being behind the assas­si­na­tion of Lebanese reformist Prime Min­is­ter Rafik Hariri.

So, what then does mat­ter to so many West­ern­ers about this war?

Our fear, of course. We want to avoid messy com­pli­ca­tions like stir­ring up another 9/11 or Madrid bomb­ing, spik­ing oil prices to over $80 a bar­rel, or tread­ing on polit­i­cally incor­rect ground by crit­i­ciz­ing the “other” of the for­mer Third World .

The West­ern press — usu­ally so care­ful to con­demn hate speech — is utterly silent about Arab racism. But a Euro­pean paper recently pub­lished a car­toon por­tray­ing Israeli Prime Min­is­ter Ehud Olmert as a Nazi, secure that no rabbi would issue threats that could cost the edi­tors their heads.

Still, when this is all over, we should not worry about the sur­vival of Israel . For weeks, pun­dits have been lec­tur­ing how canny and adept Hezbol­lah has proved — and how a clumsy Israel could only respond by destroy­ing Lebanon ‘s infra­struc­ture. Yet, when the dust set­tles, the world will learn that Lebanon out­side Hezbollah’s domain is not destroyed. And, one hopes, those who have suf­fered in the Hezbollah-controlled south will reex­am­ine their sup­port for a ter­ror­ist orga­ni­za­tion that has brought them — and itself — to near ruin.

Instead far more wor­ri­some is the moral cri­sis in the West itself. If so many of its politi­cians, intel­lec­tu­als and media will not or can­not fathom moral dif­fer­ences in this war, they will hardly be able to see them any­where else.

Discussion

No comments for “Worry About the West — Not Israel”

Post a comment

ESSENTIAL BACKGROUND

Martin BormannMartin Borman, Nazi in Exile by Paul Manning. German corporate capital flight program in the waning years of WWII.
Available for download. Read more about the Bormann Organizaton »